August 31, 1998.
To:Community and Neighbourhood Services Committee
Advisory Committee on Homeless and Socially Isolated Persons
From:Commissioner of Community Services
Subject:The Public Housing Inquiry
Purpose:
The Community and Neighbourhood Services Committee on July 16, 1998 had before it a
report from Councillor Jack Layton and Ms. Alison Kemper, Co-Chairs, Advisory
Committee on Homeless and Socially Isolated Persons, urging Council to endorse a series of
recommendations contained in The Public Housing Inquiry Final Report and indicating that
the Advisory Committee supports the directions of the Public Housing Inquiry. The report
was referred to the Commissioner of Community and Neighbourhood Services for a report
thereon to the Community and Neighbourhood Services Committee and to the Advisory
Committee. This report has been prepared in response to that request.
Financial Implications:
No financial implications have been identified.
Recommendations:
It is recommended that Council:
1.receive the report of The Public Housing Inquiry;
2. inform the members of The Public Housing Inquiry of the City's intention to consult with
social housing tenants and providers in developing its capacity to administer the social
housing programs; and
3. request that the Commissioner of Community and Neighbourhood Services report back
on plans for the consultations.
Council Reference/Background:
Background:
A Public Housing Inquiry was held in Toronto on Saturday March 28, 1998. The mandate of
the Panel of Inquiry was to receive deputations from tenants, tenant associations and other
interested parties concerning the future of social housing in Ontario, and to produce a set of
recommendations for reform of social housing which reflect the voices heard at the Inquiry.
Over 30 oral and written deputations, from deputants from across the Province, were
received by 8 panel members. Information on the membership of the Inquiry Panel and a list
of deputants is included an as appendix to this report.
The Inquiry was convened to give tenants of social housing a voice in social housing
reform. This was considered crucial as tenants had not been included in the membership of
the Social Housing Committee or any of its work groups.
Summary of Public Housing Inquiry Recommendations:
Three major themes emerged from the day of hearings:
-Ontario is in the midst of a housing crisis, with a lack of affordable housing;
-the senior levels of government must continue to pay for social housing and support the
development of new housing; and
-social housing tenants, who pay a large portion of the costs of operating social housing
through their rents, must be involved in making decisions which will affect their
communities, particularly the social hosing reform process.
Based on the feedback received, the Panel made recommendations in the following areas:
-Mandate of social housing
-Role of Governments in Social Housing
-Keeping Housing Affordable, the rent-geared to income (RGI) subsidy system
-Tenants Rights
-Privatization of Management in Social Housing.
Discussion:
The Inquiry report and recommendations propose that social housing be viewed as an
important component of a continuum of social and community services, with a unique role
that goes beyond that of the private sector. They also emphasize the importance of tenants'
rights is social housing, as well as tenant involvement in decision making on issues that
affect their homes and communities. Particular reference is made to tenant participation in
the social housing reform process which is currently underway. In addition,
recommendations are made with respect to keeping public housing in the public domain,
ensuring its on-going affordability, making sure it is well maintained and preserving the
current level of supply. Sale of scattered units owned by the Ontario Housing Corporation is
opposed.
The Inquiry also opposes the devolution of financial responsibility for social housing to the
property tax base and advocates for renewed federal and provincial investment in building
affordable housing.
Many of the positions taken in the report and recommendations are ones which have been
supported by the City, its housing companies or the former municipalities over the years.
Tenants have served as members of the Boards of the municipal housing companies and a
tenant-driven process is currently in place to define a tenant participation strategy for the
amalgamated housing company. The City has supported initiatives to prevent homelessness
and minimize evictions and has certainly taken strong views on the need for on-going
federal and provincial support in housing.
In one area, the privatization of property management for social housing, the City has not
yet come to any clear conclusions. The City has opposed the privatization of property
management proposed by the Metropolitan Toronto Housing Authority (MTHA), but, to
date, this opposition has been on the basis of lack of consultation with the City, rather than
on the merits of the decision. Nevertheless, the recommendations with respect to evaluating
all the options, full tenant consultation and ensuring the quality and safety of the housing
environment can be supported.
As the City begins to define its role as the administrator of social housing, the issues and
recommendations contained in the report of The Public Housing Inquiry will provide useful
background information. In addition, meaningful tenant participation will be an important
component of the City's efforts to prepare itself to administer the social housing within its
jurisdiction.
Contact Name:
Joanne Campbell
Phone: 392-7885
Fax: 392-0548
Joanne Campbell
General Manager, Shelter Housing and Support Division
Shirley Hoy
Commissioner of Community and Neighbourhood Services