Agreement Between the Former City of Toronto
and COTAPSAI (City of Toronto Administrative,
Professional Supervisory Association, Incorporated
The Corporate Services Committee recommends the adoption of Recommendations (a)
and (b) embodied in the following communication (August 31, 1998) from the
President, City of Toronto Administrative, Professional Supervisory Association,
Incorporated, (COTAPSAI) viz:
"(a)that the City be directed to adhere to Existing Exit Program for those eligible in
accordance with the recommendations adopted by City Council on June 3, 1998; and
(b)that the City undertake to apply those provisions to those eligible employees that
remain in the City's employment that have been appointed to alternative positions but
at a lower wage grade since amalgamation;";
and reports having requested the Executive Director of Human Resources to submit a
report thereon to Council for its meeting scheduled to be held on October 1, 1998.
I am writing to you to express our deep concerns about the lack of adherence to several key
provisions in the agreement between COTAPSAI and the former City of Toronto. As you
know, the adoption by City Council of the recommendations of the Commissioner of
Corporate Services on June 3, 1998, ensured that the terms and conditions of employment
for non-union employees covered by our agreement will continue until appropriate notice is
given respecting any changes or amendments to their terms and conditions of employment
and until such time as the appropriate notice period has been completed (Recommendation
No. (4) embodied in Clause No. 3 of Report No. 7 of the Corporate Services Committee.)
Background:
In accordance with Appendix "N" of the Consolidated Memorandum of Understanding, an
employee is eligible to participate in the Exit and Retirement Incentives for Surplus
Employees if the employee's position has been eliminated by streamlining or operating
budget reduction approved by City Council, and the employee has been placed into an
alternative position, but at a lower salary grade (with salary protection).
During the first few Department and Division reorganization in 1998, several situations have
arisen where such eligible employees have been placed into alternative positions at lower
salary grades. These eligible employees no longer maintain any of their previous
management responsibilities. In past reorganizations, when this situation did arise, the
employee was given a letter by the City indicating that they were eligible for the Exit
Program. I have attached a sample of one of these letters. I can provide other is you wish.
Our Association has repeatedly raised concerns with management in Human Resources in
Corporate Services that these employees are eligible to receive the same letter, but to no
avail. We believe that City Council and the Members of Corporate Services intended that
the City honour the agreement until such time that appropriate notice is given respecting
changes or amendments to their terms and conditions and until such time as the appropriate
notice period has been completed. No such notice has been given. The agreement remains in
effect.
Recommendations:
Therefore, we recommend that Corporate Services and Personnel Committees adopt the
following recommendations:
(a)That the City be directed to adhere to Existing Exit Program for those eligible in
accordance with the recommendations adopted by City Council on June 3, 1998; and
(b)That the City undertake to apply those provisions to those eligible employees that remain
in the City's employment that have been appointed to alternative positions but at a lower
wage grade since amalgamation.
On behalf of all our members throughout the City of Toronto, I welcome the opportunity to
bring our concerns forward to the next Corporate Services Committee for consideration.
_______
Mr. David Neil, President, City of Toronto Administrative, Professional Supervisory
Association, Incorporated, (COTAPSAI) appeared before the Corporate Services Committee
in connection with the foregoing matter.
(A copy of the sample letter given to employees by the former City of Toronto indicating
that they were eligible for the Exit Program, was forwarded to all Members of Council with
the September 14, 1998, agenda of the Corporate Services Committee, and a copy thereof is
also on file in the office of the City Clerk.)