Response to Information Requested About Parking Enforcement
Issues and Feasibility of Placing Parking Tag Revenues
Into a Reserve
The Strategic Policies and Priorities Committee recommends the adoption of the
recommendations of the Budget Committee contained in the following transmittal letter
(October13,1998) from the City Clerk:
Recommendation:
The Budget Committee on October 13, 1998 recommended to the Strategic Policies and
Priorities Committee and Council that:
(1)the Chief of Police provide a monthly report on absenteeism through the Police Services
Board, to the Emergency and Protective Services Committee and the Budget Committee;
(2)the Police Services Board secure full civilianisation of the remaining four parking
enforcement officers;
(3)the Chief Administrative Officer report back by the end of 1998 on the feasibility of
incorporating parking enforcement and other related parking functions into an authority or
department; and
(4)the parking tag revenues not be removed from the corporate revenue stream.
Deputy Chief Reesor and Superintendent Gary Beamish appeared before the Committee in
connection with this matter.
Background:
The Budget Committee on October 13, 1998, had before it a report (August 28, 1998) from
the Chairman, Toronto Police Services Board entitled, "Response to Information Requested
about Parking Enforcement Issues".
--------
(Report dated August 28, 1998 addressed to the
Toronto Budget Committee from the
Chairman, Toronto Police Services Board
titled, "Information Requested by the City of Toronto
Budget Committee Relating to Parking Enforcement")
Recommendation:
It is recommended that the following report be received for information.
Council Reference/Background History:
At its meeting on August 27, 1998, the Toronto Police Services Board was in receipt of the
following report July 20, 1998, from David J. Boothby, Chief of Police:
Recommendation:
That the Board receive this report for information, and that a copy be forwarded to the City of
Toronto Budget Committee.
Background:
At the meeting of March 11, 1998, the Budget Committee of the City of Toronto requested the
Toronto Police Service respond to a number of issues affecting the Parking Enforcement
Unit's 1998 budget.
This report provides the requested responses. The delay in response occurred because the
transmittal letter dated March 18, 1998 did not include all of the recommendations made by
the Budget Committee. The corrected letter was forwarded July 7, 1998.
(2)the Parking Enforcement Unit to:
(b)establish a target to reduce absenteeism from 9 per cent to 5 per cent and that it provide a
plan on how this can be done;
Parking Enforcement staff reported sick/injured on average of 3.4 times during 1997. In
addition to the outdoor requirements, enforcement duties involve particular challenges. For
example, over the past two years nearly 90 assault charges have been laid resulting from
incidents involving Parking Enforcement Officers on duty.
Unit management is taking a number of initiatives to minimize absenteeism.
The Supervisor of Administration has been assigned responsibility of ensuring sick staff
comply with all Service requirements (e.g. doctor's letters), are reassessed when specified by
the Service's Medical Advisory Service and take whatever steps are required to return the
employee to work as soon as their situation permits.
With the assistance of Human Resources, strategies have been developed to assist long term
light duty staff enhance their job skills qualifying them for reclassification and placement in
other units. Replacement Parking Enforcement Officers are then hired, improving unit
productivity. Since January, two officers have been reclassified and several others are
currently within this program.
(c)take the necessary action to civilianize the last remaining parking enforcement positions;
that the Toronto Police Service be thanked for its efforts with regard to parking enforcement;
and that the Parking Enforcement Unit report back to the Budget Committee before the 1998
budget wrap-up meeting on the cost of these positions and how the budget will be adjusted;
The Unit updated the Police Services Board in November 1997 on its progress with
civilianization. The following quote from the Board Letter (minute 453/97) summarizes both
the progress and issues involved
"Since its inception the Parking Enforcement Unit has made consistent progress towards its
target of fully civilianizing the Unit. The position reclassification report approved by the
Board on February 26, 1997 deleted one third of the remaining uniform positions. The key
challenge faced in securing full civilianization of the final six positions is the current lack of
fully qualified operational staff. To address this issue in mid 1997 a civilian supervisory
position was created on an acting basis to replace one of the sergeants. This will provide a
career development opportunity eventually leading to permanent civilianization.
In the shorter term, plans are underway to civilianize the Staff Sergeant position, achieving
full civilianization of that section in 1998"
The report civilianizing the Staff Sergeant position is contained in the current Board agenda,
and will generate a net savings in the 1999 estimates.
(d)report back to the Budget Committee with information on the number of parking
enforcement officers that may be required to meet the demands of the calls received; the costs
related thereto; and the effect on the revenue and expenses of the Parking Enforcement Unit.
The average Parking Enforcement Officer provides a net revenue of approximately
$113,000.00 for the City, equivalent to 2.25 times the cost of the position.
Over the last 12 months the Unit suffered higher than usual staffing shortfalls due to constable
recruitment. This situation will be resolved by 1998 hiring. Parking Enforcement staff have
reviewed the current establishment and believe that it is adequate to meet the City's
enforcement needs.
Superintendent Gary Beamish (8-6653) will be present at the Board meeting to answer any
questions.
Conclusions:
The Board received the foregoing.
Contact Name and Telephone Number:
Superintendent Gary Beamish, Parking Enforcement Unit, telephone no. 808-6653.