On December 5, 2024, City staff will present a Status Report on the Office Study to the Planning and Housing Committee. The report will cover findings, next steps for office replacement policies, and the consultant’s final report. The agenda, including the report, will be available on November 28.

 

The City is undertaking a study to analyze current office market conditions, understand the benefits and risks of converting office space to alternative uses, and explore policy options that would balance office needs in the short-term and long-term, while ensuring the City’s economic role remains competitive and resilient.

The consultant’s final report on the office study is now complete and is summarized in the Executive Summary of the Needs Assessment & Policy Options report. If you have any questions or comments regarding the report, please contact Rory McNeil.

Increasing office vacancies is a trend impacting large cities across North America as companies adjust to hybrid work following the COVID-19 Pandemic. These challenges have prompted several municipalities to introduce interventions, including financial support for businesses, cultural events, promotion and marketing, infrastructure investments, and enabling office-to-housing conversions.

Concurrently, Toronto is experiencing a prolonged housing crisis that has elevated pressures for residential intensification. In part, this increased pressure has led to development applications that propose to add residential uses above existing office buildings, convert office to residential uses, or demolish office buildings entirely. The loss of office space is typically a permanent outcome that cannot be reversed later if market conditions change. Considering Toronto’s important economic role as Canada’s largest concentration of office employment and corporate headquarters, any resulting policy decision should be informed by comprehensive analysis.

The Office Space Needs Study will include an office market analysis, weigh the benefits and risks of office space conversion, and explore policy options that balance office needs in the short-term and long-term.

A consultant has been retained to support the Study which will be conducted in three phases.

Phase One (October 2023 to February 2024) – Complete:

  • Conduct a background review of City and Provincial policies and City economic development related programs;
  • Conduct a background review of recent and ongoing office-related development and current office market trends;
  • Conduct stakeholder interviews with a diversity of office and non-residential sectors; and
  • Prepare a background report summarizing phase one which will be made available on the Study website.

Phase Two (February 2024 to July 2024):

  • Develop short-term and long-term projections of office space needs to accommodate anticipated employment growth under a range of future scenarios;
  • Explore office space conversion, including both residential and non-residential in a Toronto-specific context including by sub-areas and building typologies;
  • Develop policy and program options to address the current challenges of the City’s office market, with near- and long-term outcomes being considered;
  • Present at a public meeting hosted by City staff; and
  • Prepare a findings report summarizing the findings and analysis of the study which will be made available on the Study website.

Phase Three (August 2024 to November 2024)

  • Conduct further analysis on incentive programs for conversions of office to alternative non-residential uses and affordable housing;
  • Conduct an economic and sensitivity analysis to test various office replacement rates;
  • Consult on conversions of office to purpose built rental housing and policies to facilitate it.

The Study directions will be summarized with applicable policy and program recommendations by City staff in a report to Council.

The City tracks key social and economic indicators including office vacancies reported via Toronto’s Dashboard.

Final Report – Needs Assessment & Policy Options

The Executive Summary of the consultant’s final report, titled “Needs Assessment & Policy Options,” is now available. If you would like to review the full Needs Assessment & Policy Options report, please contact Rory McNeil.

Staff Proposals Report

At its meeting on July 11, 2024, Planning and Housing Committee endorsed the proposed policy directions outlined in PH14.9 and requested City Planning to undertake further analysis and consultation on office replacement. A final report is expected in the fourth quarter of 2024.

Background Report

The Executive Summary of the Background Report is now available. If you would like to review the full Background Report please contact Rory McNeil.

Motion to Explore Incentives for Office Conversion into Other Employment Uses

At it’s meeting on February 6, 2024 City Council requested City Planning and Economic Development and Culture to explore opportunities to provide financial incentives, policies and other options to support the conversion or adaptation of vacant office space into other non-residential employment uses, including the potential to utilize as a funding source for such efforts savings from lower than forecast Tax Increment Equivalent Grants payments to office developments covered by an Imagination, Manufacturing, Innovation and Technology (IMIT) Program Financial Incentive Agreement experiencing high vacancy rates. More information can be found in EX11.6.

Motion to Explore the Potential for Office Conversions and Affordable Housing

At it’s meeting on November 8, 2022 City Council requested City Planning and Economic Development and Culture to study potential conversion of office space across the City into new housing, consider what zoning and other regulatory or policy relief may be required to enable economically-viable office conversions and evaluate the feasibility of requiring the provision of affordable housing in lieu of the replacement of office space. More information regarding the motion can be found in PH7.9.

Meeting information, registration details and other engagement opportunities will be posted here when available.

Rental and Affordable Housing Stakeholder Interviews – October to November 2024

Research interviews with purpose-built-rental and affordable housing industry stakeholders were held to solicit information on the challenges associated with office conversions to rental housing, the potential for affordable housing within purpose-built-rental development, and the set of incentives and funding options available for purpose-built-rental and affordable housing development. A summary of key themes resulting from the interviews can be found in staff’s report to December 5, 2024 Planning and Housing Committee.

Stakeholder Interviews – December 2023 to January 2024

Stakeholder research interviews were held to solicit direct, on-the-ground feedback from local property and asset managers, the development community and other groups involved in the commercial real estate sector. A summary of key themes resulting from the interviews can be found in the Office Space Needs Study Background Report.

Stakeholder Consultation – May 14

Stakeholder Consultation was held on May 14 where the study team met with local property and asset managers, the development community and other groups involved in the commercial real estate sector to discuss the preliminary findings of the Study.

Community Consultation – May 15

Community Consultation was held on May 15 to discuss the preliminary findings of the Study with the community and solicit feedback. The study team presented:

  • Office market findings and projections;
  • Feasibility analysis of conversions;
  • Considerations on balancing employment opportunities and housing needs; and
  • Policy options for discussion.

Please contact Rory McNeil for a copy of the Community Consultation presentation material.

The Office Space Needs Study will include consultation in a variety of forms over the course of the study. Please contact Rory McNeil with any questions or comments.