Register for the upcoming virtual public meeting on May 17, 2022. Review public meeting presentation part 1 and part 2. Complete survey before May 31, 2022.

 

Originally a 1.4 km gap in the Humber River Trail (HRT) near Weston Road and Lawrence Avenue West, approximately 800 metres of trail remains to be completed. This gap constitutes a significant barrier to a continuous multi-use trail system both along the HRT and in the future Loop Trail. The Loop trail is an 65 km off road, multi-use ring that will connect multiple ravines, neighbourhoods and trail systems throughout Toronto. Existing routes present safety concerns to users who are forced to detour along busy local roads that lack designated cycling infrastructure and are not fully accessible.

The study is being conducted in partnership by Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (TRCA) and City of Toronto.

This Study has evaluated options and identified a preliminary preferred trail alignment that will close the existing gap in the HRT network. The preliminary preferred trail alignment includes an in-valley alignment, paved multi-use trail, including two pedestrian-cycle bridges with elevated boardwalk.

Members of the public are invited to provide feedback and ask questions. Public consultation will be conducted online, by phone and by mail.

Virtual Public Meeting

The meeting will include a project update and an opportunity to ask questions and provide feedback on the preferred trail alignment. A meeting summary will be provided afterwards on this web page.

  • Date: Tuesday, May 17, 2022
  • Time: 6:30 – 8:30 p.m.
  • Join by computer, smartphone or tablet:
    • Register: Receive meeting link and password by email
  • Join by phone (audio only):
    • Five minutes before the meeting starts, call 416-915-6530 and enter Access Code 2468 301 8779. Call in starting at 6:25 p.m.

How to Join a City WebEx Event

  • If this is your first time participating in a City Virtual Meeting, learn how to use the Webex Events platform.
  • If you require accommodation or assistive services, please contact Maogosha Pyjor at 416-338-2850 or maogosha.pyjor@toronto.ca to identify what can be provided.

Meeting Materials and Survey

Get Involved

Public consultation is an important element of the study. You will have opportunities for input at key stages throughout the project. Information about future public consultation events will be distributed by mail and posted here. If you have questions or comments, or would like to receive email project updates, please contact us at 416-338-2850 or email maogosha.pyjor@toronto.ca

The Mid Humber Gap project area is located between two completed sections of the Humber River Trail (HRT) just south of Mallaby Park and west of St. Phillips Road and the southern entrance to Crawford-Jones Memorial Park off Cardell Avenue.

Project area is bounded by Weston Road to the east, Cardell Avenue to the north, west side of the Humber River for to the west and St.Phillips Road just south of Humber River for the southern point. A railway runs east west through the middle of the area which is situated south of the 401.

Stakeholder Advisory Group

A Stakeholder Advisory Group (SAG) comprised of stakeholder representatives and local residents was formed to review and provide feedback throughout the Environment Assessment process. The SAG assists in building a consensus on the Mid Humber Gap’s primary objective – to identify a preferred multi-use trail alignment for the remaining approximately 800 metre gap in the Humber River Trail (HRT).

Meeting Summary 1

Presentation
  • The City and TRCA presented to the SAG on Wednesday, May 5, 2021, on the SAG Terms of Reference, project background, Municipal Class Environmental Assessment process, planning context, preliminary screen matrix, and project timeline.
Comments
  • Comments about private land trust and Option 1A (In-Valley) – can private landowners veto any potential alignment options that are proposed on their property
  • The trail should accommodate all users and avoid conflict where possible (e.g., avoiding steep slopes and ensuring adequate width).
  • Pedestrian safety concerns along a very busy Weston Road.
  • Proposed trail slope concerns at Mallaby Park for Options 2A (On-Road, In-Valley) and 3A (On-Road). Steep slopes will be problematic for children and users with mobility issues.
  • Flooding and erosion concerns with inquiry about studies to ensure any trail safety and longevity.
  • How soon can the trail be built?
  • Several SAG members voiced their preference for Option 1A over Option 2A and 3A
Staff Responses
  • Metrolinx, the private land trust, and the Weston Golf and Country Club have been engaged in discussions.
  • Preliminary preferred alignments that are proposed to intersect with private lands will require further discussions with impacted landowners and these discussions are ongoing.
  • Option 3A is an on-road alignment with dedicated cycling facilities along Weston Road. The project team will be investigating the feasibility of this Option and the modifications and impacts required to implement a safe route along Weston Road (e.g., potential land reductions, shifting of existing utilities, etc.).
  • The preliminary preferred alignments (Options 1A, 2A, and 3A) are still at the conceptual stage and will be further refined as the project progresses into the detailed evaluation phase.
  • A portion of Option 1A is proposed to route along Weston Golf and Country Club property. Optimizing trail design in this area to reduce impacts to course layout will be explored as part of the MCEA process and discussions with landowners are ongoing.
  • The commencement of construction will depend on the completion of the MCEA and detailed design phase, acquisition of permits and approvals, and available budget.

Meeting Summary 2

Presentation
  • The City and TRCA presented to the SAG on Thursday, February 3, 2022, on the Preliminary Preferred Trail Alignments, Evaluation Matrix and Design Considerations for Preferred Alignment.
Key topics and Staff Responses

Private Land Trust and location of trail from individual’s homes

  • While subject to change during detailed design, the current alignment is located within the ravine and far from the private residential properties on Humberview Crescent. Fencing will also be proposed as an additional privacy and security measure, the location and details of which will be developed in detailed design in consultation with residents.

Weston Golf and Country Club (WGCC) and potential safety risks, trail users and flood events and mitigation

  • While the southern bridge and elevated boardwalk would include a protective enclosure, the decking of both structures is designed to be above more frequent flooding events. As with similar trail networks found throughout Toronto’s ravines, rigorous design, engineering, and safety standards will be applied to all structures posed within the floodplain.
  • TRCA and the City have a significant network of existing trails and bridge crossings within similar ravine settings, where flooding does occur. Design standards are being followed that will minimize risk to user safety and property. Signage and other features could also be included to notify the public. The MCEA and detailed design process will include safety and mitigation measures as needed, based on existing conditions and guided by TRCA/City standards for ravine trail systems.

Preferred Trail Alignment and maintenance

  • Parks, Forestry & Recreation Operations team’s responsibility to complete ongoing or emergency maintenance and garbage collection.
  • Planning, design, and permitting of all infrastructure within floodplains is regulated by TRCA, which has a primary interest in protecting ravine habitat and avoiding increased risk to property and the public, The preferred alignment and crossings reflect site conditions and design guidelines typical for a number of similar projects within Toronto’s extensive ravine and trail system, including the East Don Trail and Upper Highland Creek Pan Am Path.

Bike Lane Considerations for Weston Road and facility options

  • Accommodating a bi-directional cycle track would require significant modification to the existing road configuration, including private property acquisition. The Transportation Analysis undertaken as part of the MCEA indicated a significant increased risk to cycle track users and pedestrians due to a likely increase in vehicle-user conflict along driveways. In addition, if the proposal was for uni-directional cycle tracks, a safe crossing from the one-way cycle track facility to the trail would be needed, particularly at the intersection of St. Phillips and Weston Rd.
  • Considering Weston Road is a busy arterial roadway near Hwy 401, lane removals may impact traffic flow including the potential to negatively impact public transit in the area.

Trail Accessibility considerations

  • Several SAG members voiced their preference for Option 1A over Option 2A and 3A, primarily due to the gentler grades proposed for this alignment. Option 1A also provides an in-valley alignment, allowing users to enjoy the ravine and naturalized space.

Flooding and Erosion assessment inquiry

  • As part of the MCEA process, comprehensive flood modelling and geomorphic study has been undertaken to ensure all proposed crossings are carefully sited, sufficiently sized, and appropriately designed. These studies will help determine the planning and design of the trail system and the level of protection required to ensure they are safe (e.g., scour protection measures for bridge abutments and minimum clearances for bridge decking).

Construction commencement

  • The commencement of construction will depend on completing the MCEA and detailed design phase, acquisition of permits and approvals, and available budget. Given the MCEA process is planned to be completed in early 2022, construction may commence in 2024, and extend over a few years, assuming the budget, permits, and approvals have been secured.

Public Events

Consultation for the Mid Humber Gap Trail has engaged a broad range of residents, businesses, and stakeholders over two rounds of engagement.

Virtual Public Meeting 1

The City hosted a virtual public meeting on June 10, 2021 from 6:30 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. The meeting was attended by 77 participants who contributed to a very thoughtful and informative discussion.

Project team members presented on the study background, process and potential trail alignments. Three potential trail alignments were highlighted: in-ravine (1A); hybrid in-ravine and on-road (2A) and on-road (3A).

Common themes and topics during the discussion covered areas of accessibility, personal and road safety, trail user experience, impacts to the natural environment, and community benefits (e.g. recreation). Many people talked about the importance of filling this significant trail gap along the iconic Humber River which benefits both area residents and trail users within the city. Several participants voiced their preference for Option 1A (the in-ravine alignment) noting that it keeps users in-valley and avoids steep slopes making the trail more accessible to all trail users (e.g., children, strollers, the elderly, etc.). Some concern about Option 3A (Weston Road alignment) given traffic volumes and safety issues. Property owners within the project area also raised their concerns with potential impacts associated with in-ravine alignment including: trail user safety, wildlife habitat, sustainability of the trail, flooding, and vandalism on the golf course.

The three trail alignments are still at the conceptual stage and will be further assessed as the project progresses into the detailed evaluation phase. As part of the Environmental Assessment process the environmental impacts are always considered along with user safety and impacts to private property.

See materials presented at the event and a full summary of questions, comments and responses below.

Project History

The Mid Humber Gap Project was one of 26 projects identified in the Bikeway Trails Implementation Plan adopted by Toronto City Council in 2012 and a near-term priority in the 2019 Cycling Network Plan Update.

Stage 1 – Trail Construction and Improvement Work (Completed 2013)

In 2013, the City and Toronto & Region Conservation Authority (TRCA) completed Stage 1 of the Mid Humber Gap project. During Stage 1, a 600-metre trail was constructed to connect Mallaby Park to the HRT system and a pre-existing dirt trail was formalized into a 3.5 metre-wide paved multi-use pathway.

Stage 2 – Feasibility Study (Completed 2019)

In 2019, the City and TRCA completed Stage 2 of the Mid Humber Gap project to evaluate conceptual trail alignment options to close the remaining gap of approximately 800 m in the HRT between Mallaby Park and Crawford-Jones Memorial Park.

The Feasibility Study provides a project rationale for pursuing Stage 3 – Municipal Engineer Class EA (MCEA) Schedule B Planning Process. The Feasibility Study evaluated a range of conceptual trail alignments, culminating in a recommended “in-ravine” and “on-road” option.

Trail alignment constraints include steep grades, challenging topography and private property considerations.   These constraints increase the complexity of the project and may require construction of bridges, boardwalk structures and negotiations with private landowners. The Feasibility Study also confirmed the need to conduct a more thorough investigation via an MCEA Schedule B process.

Stage 3 – Municipal Engineer Class Environmental Assessment Schedule B Planning Process (Ongoing)

The Mid Humber Gap is currently in Stage 3 and subject to MCEA Schedule B requirements.

Environmental Assessment Process

Building off the work already completed as part of a Feasibility Study undertaken in 2019, the planning and design of the Mid Humber Gap will follow the Schedule B requirements for a Municipal Engineer Class EA (MCEA) process. The MCEA meets the intent of the EA Act by providing for the identification of problems or opportunities; giving due regard to the need to protect the environment and minimize effects; and consulting with affected stakeholders early and throughout the decision making process (Municipal Engineers Association, amended 2015).

Schedule

March 31, 2021

  • Notice of Commencement issued by the City of Toronto and Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (TRCA) to identify a preferred multi-use trail alignment for the remaining gap in the Humber River Trail (HRT) just south of Mallaby Park at St. Phillips Road and the southern entrance to Crawford-Jones Memorial Park off Cardell Avenue. Notification was circulated to everyone in the study area which is bounded by the 401 (north), Lawrence Street (south), Islington Avenue (west) and Pelmo Park/Elm Street (east).

April 2021

  • Identify Preliminary Preferred Trail Alignments

June 10, 2021

  • Public Information Centre 1

November 2021 – March 2022

  • Stakeholder and public consultation on the preliminary preferred
  • Evaluation and Selection of Preferred Alignment

May 2022

  • Public Information Centre 2
  • Refine Conceptual Design of Preferred Alignment

Summer 2022

  • Finalize and Submit Project File Report
  • Issue Notice of Completion

Evaluation Process

The study will consider the following items to determine the location and alignment for the new trail connection:

  • natural environment
  • residents and property owners in the focus area and the surrounding area
  • user accessibility, safety and experience
  • technical feasibility/constructability
  • capital (upfront) and lifecycle (long-term) costs

Following the first virtual Stakeholder Advisory Group and Public Meeting, the potential connection options will be evaluated and a preferred alternative will be recommended based on the outcome of the evaluation and public feedback.

Information used in the evaluation will be collected through existing reports, field studies, input from technical advisors and subject matter experts and through public consultation.

Study Outcome

All potential alignments for the multi-use trail, both individually and collectively, will be studied in order to provide a preferred trail alignment to complete approximately 800 metres of the Humber River.

The preferred trail alignment will be decided as per a formal Environmental Assessment (EA) process and followed by design/construction programmed in future years (based on budget ability).

Property Impacts

Some of the potential multi-use trail alignments that are being proposed could involve impacts to residential and commercial properties. In some cases, the potential impact is to the City-owned right of way.

The owners of properties that are potentially impacted by multi-use trail alignments will be engaged with directly by the City of Toronto and Toronto & Region Conservation Authority (TRCA).

Private property impacts will be considered as part of the detailed evaluation criteria used to determine the recommended alignment.

Need assistance?  While we aim to provide fully accessible content, there is no text alternative available for some of the content on this page. If you require alternate formats or need assistance understanding our maps, drawings or any other content, please contact us at 416-338-2850 or email maogosha.pyjor@toronto.ca