Homes and buildings generate about 57 per cent of the greenhouse gas emissions in Toronto today, mainly from the burning of fossil fuels (primarily natural gas) for heating and hot water. Heat pumps are a greener alternative to traditional heating systems. They work well in cold temperatures and are suitable for winters in Toronto. In fact, a cold-climate heat pump system can completely replace the furnace or boiler in your home as well as the air-conditioner.
Most people will consider a heat pump when their furnace and/or air-conditioner is approaching end-of-life, but you should have a plan before your furnace or air conditioner breaks down. Steps you can take now to be ready for a heat pump installation in the future include:
In the summer, a heat pump acts like an air conditioner by extracting heat from the air inside your home. In the winter, the heat pump works in reverse to provide heating. The basic parts of a heat pump are the same as those of an air-conditioner or a refrigerator. They’ve just been enhanced to allow for heating.
Both air-conditioners and heat pumps have:
Unlike an air-conditioner, a heat pump also has a reversing valve that allows it to pump heat in either direction (into the home or out of the home) to provide heating as well as cooling.
Air-source heat pumps are the most common type used in existing homes in urban settings. They absorb (or reject) energy from the outside air for heating and cooling. Normally, air-source heat pumps are split systems which means that there is a coil outside of your home and a coil inside your home. In heating season, the outdoor coil absorbs heat energy from cold outdoor air, the compressor upgrades it and the indoor coil provides the heating to the home. During the cooling season in the summer, the heat pump operates like a regular air conditioner.
Ground-source heat pumps use the stable temperature of the earth (rather than the outside air) as the source for heating and cooling, making them the most efficient option for homes and buildings. A heat pump on the inside of the home connects to piping installed in the ground outside the home. The ground-source heat pump can be centrally-ducted, like a furnace, or be used to provide hot water to radiant heating systems. These systems are increasingly common in rural homes and large buildings but also possible in urban homes. Ground-source heat pumps have the highest efficiencies and lowest electrical demand requirements.
A heat pump must be sized correctly for your home. Natural Resources Canada has developed a toolkit to help installers size and select air-source heat pumps.
For more information on how heat pumps work to cool and heat your home, visit Natural Resources Canada’s webpage.
Heat pumps are typically air-source or ground-source and there are a range of options.
|Centrally-ducted air-source heat pumps||This type connects to the ductwork in a home in the same way as a furnace and central air-conditioner and they look similar to a furnace and air-conditioner. They normally have a back-up heating source, such as an electric resistance heating coil installed as a package with the heat pump. With a hybrid air-source heat pump system, a traditional furnace is used as a back up.|
|Ductless air-source heat pumps||Ductless heat pumps are used when there is no existing ductwork inside the home. The indoor unit can be mounted to the wall, floor, or in the ceiling. Mini-split systems have one outdoor unit connected to one indoor unit. Each unit heats and cools one room or zone of a home. Multi-split systems have multiple indoor units connected to a single outdoor unit, which together provide heating or cooling for the entire house.
|Cold-climate air-source heat pumps||These work in extreme cold conditions. They can be centrally-ducted, ductless, or even be used in hybrid systems, which include a traditional furnace. Conventional air-source heat pumps (i.e. not cold-climate ones) must revert to a back-up heating option when outdoor temperatures go below -15 degrees Celsius.|
|Hybrid systems: Air-source plus a furnace||Hybrid systems are sometimes referred to as dual-fuel systems, and utilize both a traditional furnace and an air-source heat pump. The heat pump replaces the home’s air-conditioner and also provides most of the heating. Refer to the next section for more information.|
|Air-to-water heat pumps||This type of heat pump heats water rather than the air inside a home. They can be used in homes that have radiant heating systems.|
In a hybrid system, a heat pump is typically used in milder conditions and the furnace is used in more extreme cold. The furnace and heat pump are not used at the same time. The heat pump is also used for cooling.
Hybrid systems can be lower cost than all-electric (no traditional furnace) options because the heat pump does not need to operate in extreme cold nor does it need to meet the full heating requirements of the home. This means the heat pump can be relatively smaller and simpler – and as a result, it can also be a higher-end model.
There are two main ways to coordinate switching between the furnace and heat pump. The simplest way is to select an outdoor switch-over temperature. Above that outdoor temperature, only the heat pump operates. Below it, only the furnace operates.
Setting the switch-over temperature to as low as possible will maximize carbon reductions because the home will be heated with the heat pump for a greater portion of time. Lower switch-over temperatures are possible with larger heat pumps and larger heat pumps are generally better from a carbon reduction perspective.
|Reductions in Natural Gas Use||84%||77%||69%||59%||47%||33%|
A large portion of the annual heating requirements for a home occur at milder outdoor temperatures. This is why the hybrid approach can result in major natural gas savings and carbon reductions.
Smart control is another way to coordinate the heat pump and furnace in a hybrid system. A smart controller can connect to the web and choose to operate either the heat pump or the furnace based on whatever costs less at any point in time. This approach can generate some of the lowest energy bills.
For example, if Ontario moves forward with ultra-low nighttime electricity rates, a system that uses smart control to prioritize off-peak heat pump operation could result in hundreds of dollars of annual savings.
There are many heat pump options. There are four key considerations when determining which is right for your home:
If there is no existing central ducting in the home, then a ductless air-source heat pump should generally be considered. If there is central ducting, then a central air-source heat pump, geoexchange system, or hybrid system is possible. However, the existing ductwork may constrain heat pump sizing. This must be evaluated by a qualified installer.
If there is an existing hydronic system (a boiler with radiators and/or radiant in-floor) then geoexchange or air-to-water heat pumps may be possible, as would a ductless air-source heat pump system. However, replacing a boiler system with a heat pump can be more complex because the temperatures provided by heat pumps are lower than the temperatures from a boiler.
This is generally not an issue with radiant in-floor systems, but can present an issue for existing radiators. Radiators may need to be upgraded to low-temperature versions. A multi-split ductless system may be a good heat pump option in this scenario but in older homes there can be hot-spotting and cold-spotting issues that need to be addressed. The ideal solution will vary with different homes.
It is most cost-effective to replace a heating and cooling system when it is near its end-of-life. If you have a newer furnace and older air-conditioner, then a hybrid system can be considered. In a hybrid system, an air-source heat pump would replace the air-conditioner and be used with the existing furnace for heating. The heat pump would provide all the cooling and much of the heating in mild temperatures. Learn more about hybrid systems in the ‘Types of Heat Pumps’ section of this web page.
Hybrid heat pump systems are the lowest cost, followed by all electric (cold climate) systems. Ground-source (geoexchange) heat pumps have the largest upfront cost. Some heat pumps are eligible for the Canada Greener Homes Grant, as well as incentives and low-interest financing through the City of Toronto’s Home Energy Loan Program.
Heat pumps are much more efficient that traditional furnaces. In the context of low- or no-interest loans, net monthly costs can be low and the total cost of ownership for a heat pump can be near that of traditional furnaces, or in some cases, lower.
Heating and cooling systems with the highest efficiency and that use the least amount of natural gas are the most environmentally friendly. Ground-source (geoexchange) heat pumps have the highest efficiencies and lowest electrical demand requirements. Premium high-performance air-source heat pumps are not far behind geoexchange in terms of efficiency. Hybrid systems can use high-efficiency or low-efficiency air-source heat pumps and they leave a natural gas option in place, but they can still generate substantial natural gas savings for a low upfront cost.
A heat pump must be sized correctly for your home. Natural Resources Canada has developed a toolkit to help installers size and select air-source heat pumps.
While the upfront costs of a heat pump are greater than traditional heating options, there are various sources of savings that can offset these costs, including government programs such as grants, rebates, carbon pricing, incentives and low-interest loans. Similar to electric vehicles, it useful to consider the total cost of ownership. Read this example case study showing a total cost of ownership calculation for a central cold-climate air-source heat pump.
Estimated upfront costs are provided below as a general reference point. For more accurate costing, homeowners are encouraged to get multiple quotes from qualified system installers in their area. Upfront costs will vary with the heat pump brand as well as the warranty, features, efficiency and heating capacity of the heat pump. It will also vary with installation-specific factors of different homes.
Note that the costs provided below do not include upgrades to ductwork that may sometimes be required. The costs also do not include upgrades of the electrical service of a home. Especially when systems are installed with full electric resistance back-up, an electrical service upgrade to 200A may be required and may cost an additional $3,500 to $5,000.
|Ductless split air-source heat pumps||Installed costs for a ductless mini-split air-source heat pump may range from $4,000 to $6,000 (pre-tax). However, a mini-split can only heat or cool one room or zone within a home. Multi-split systems may be able to heat or cool a whole home and may have a similar cost to an equivalent number of mini-splits. Ductless systems meeting eligibility criteria may qualify for up to $2,500 through the City’s Home Energy Loan Program incentives and/or rebates between $2,500 and $5,000 from the Canada Greener Homes Grant. Note that all qualifying systems must have multiple indoor heads or warm air supply outlets.|
|Centrally-ducted air-source heat pumps (all-electric)||A centrally-ducted air-source heat pump system that qualifies for the Canada Greener Homes Grant may cost from $14,500 to $22,000 (pre-tax and pre-rebate) installed. At the lower end of that spectrum are smaller systems (i.e. 2-ton and lower). The higher end of the spectrum includes larger systems. Centrally-ducted systems may qualify for a rebate of either $4,000 or $5,000 from the Canada Greener Homes Grant and/or up to $2,500 through the City’s Home Energy Loan Program incentives .|
|Hybrid: Air-source heat pump plus a furnace||For most homes, replacing an old central air-conditioner with a single-stage air-source heat pump may cost around $4,000 to $6,000 (pre-tax) installed. This may represent an additional cost of $1,000 to $3,000 over the cost of replacing an old air-conditioner with another traditional air-conditioner. Note that the Canada Greener Homes Grant and the City’s Home Energy Loan Program do not currently offer incentives or rebates for heat pumps used with existing furnaces.
A new furnace and new air-source heat pump that meets the eligibility criteria of the Canada Greener Homes Grant may cost $14,500 (pre-tax and pre-rebate) or more. A rebate of $4,000 or $5,000 may be received for these systems.
It is also possible to purchase a new furnace and new air-source heat pump that does not meet the eligibility requirements of the Canada Greener Homes Grant. In this category of equipment, a new furnace and new air-source heat pump (single- or two-stage) may cost $8,000 to $12,000 (pre-tax). Again, this may represent an additional cost of $1,000 to $3,000 versus a like-for-like replacement of a furnace-A/C system. See “Key Terms” for a description of single-stage and two-stage heat pump options.
|Geoexchange||The last largescale market analysis for geoexchange in Canada was conducted in 2011. Based on that analysis, a homeowner might expect that a new closed vertical loop geoexchange system for an existing single-family home could cost on the scale of $30,000 for a single-home retrofit in a Toronto neighbourhood (assuming a system size of 3.5 to 4.0 tons). Utility-ownership of the geoexchange system may help to eliminate the upfront cost for homeowners in exchange for a more manageable monthly fee. Ground-source (geoexchange) heat pumps have the highest efficiencies and lowest electrical demand requirements. Systems meeting the eligibility criteria of the Canada Greener Homes Grant may receive a rebate of $3,000 or $5,000.|
An electric heat pump will reduce or eliminate the use of a traditional home heating fuel, but it will also increase electricity consumption. The net utility bill savings of heat pump depends on:
It is also important to understand that the utility bill is not the only source of savings. Homeowners may be able to reduce their property insurance by making the switch to a heat pump. No- or low-interest financing available for heat pumps will reduce the cost of financing compared to traditional equipment and rebates can reduce the upfront costs. Homeowners disconnecting from gas entirely can also save the fixed customer charge paid to the gas utility. Currently (2022), it is approximately $25 per month or $300 per year. Given the variety of factors influencing savings, it is helpful to look at case studies of actual retrofits. Please see the “Case Studies” section for more information.
Heat pump installations can be similar to installations of conventional equipment. However, not every contractor is equipped to help you choose and install the right heat pump option for your home. Here are some tips to find the right contractor:
The City of Toronto is supporting the development of heat pump case studies documenting installations around the city prepared by The Sustainable Technologies Evaluation Program (STEP) of the Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (TRCA).
Case studies show the equipment installation costs, homeowner experience, utility savings and other helpful information.
The capacity of a heat pump describes its heating or cooling output. The heat pump’s rated capacity is also referred to as its size. It may be given in units of kilowatt (kW) or BTU/hour (sometimes just referred to as BTUs). The required heating and cooling capacity for a home will vary with its size, amount of insulation and air-tightness.
The COP describes the efficiency of the heat pump. It is the heat energy output divided by the energy it consumes. For example, a heat pump COP of 3 means that 3 units of heat energy are provided for every 1 unit of energy used to power it. A high-efficiency furnace can be thought of as having a COP near 0.95. COP changes with the outdoor air (or ground) temperature and is highest in warmer conditions.
The HSPF considers several factors to estimate the average efficiency of an air-source heat pump over a heating season. Heat pumps with an HSPF that has been independently determined by a third-party will have a seal that says “AHRI Certified” on the manufacturer information sheets. The HSPF may be near 8.0 on the low-end, to more than 11.0 on the high-end. A greater HSPF will mean lower electricity consumption (and utility bills).
The EER describes the cooling efficiency of an air-conditioner in hot outdoor conditions. This contrasts with the SEER which provides an estimated average cooling efficiency over the course of a summer.
The SEER is the estimated average cooling efficiency over the course of the summer. For an air-source heat pump, it may be near 13 on the low end to more than 18 on the high end. Higher SEER means lower electricity consumption for cooling.
These terms all describe the ability of a heat pump to adjust its heating output. A single-stage heat pump is either fully on or fully off. A two-stage heat pump has a high and a low setting. This is often better to promote even heating and to prevent heat pumps from being oversized for cooling. Inverter-driven variable capacity heat pumps can closely match the heat pump capacity to the needs of the home. These can achieve the best performance.